suggestion for Official Suggestions Sticky :)

[Gotfryd]

It's very good that we have Official Sticky with don't-suggest list and list of public demands. Still, I lack one thing: place to hold good, supported suggestions, but not supported enough to be public demands (a suggestion should have at least 90% support to be a public demand, and there are a lot of suggestions with about 80% support).
I suggest to make a section in Official Sticky (entitled, for example, "other supported suggestions") with list of all ideas that have between 70 and 90% support. It would help us not to forget about good ideas, and maybe prevent some double threads.

Please vote and post comments. And, if you are a moderator, implement this

[scarface09]

Yes!!! Thank you gotfryd for making this! Imo, me and Gotfryd should be moderators for this thread because we are most active and post most ideas. And then if most people agree, we will bring it up to someone higher like Echo_trail etc, and see what he says. You know what I'm saying?...

[Gotfryd]

Well, I think that it's impossible to be a moderator of a single thread, and I don't suppose they'll make us moderators of whole Game Improvements/Suggestions board, we're not experienced enough. And we have echo_trail and SadistAtHeart, the are not idle.

[scarface09]

Okay, the first topic should be on Gas Masks: the link provided here http://forums.soldat.pl/index.php?topic=30793.0

There are 17 votes supporting and 3 against it, I think it's a good idea and great for customizing and featuring your player, this should be only to registered players. What are your ideas guys?

[Gotfryd]

Scarface09, I don't want this thread to contain these "good ideas". I've created it only to discuss the idea.

[scarface09]

Yes, im saying lets discuss the Gas Masks idea.

[Gotfryd]

You don't understand me. I want to discuss here only if there should be another list in Official Suggestions Sticky containing good ideas which are not public demands.

And now everyone votes I don't know/I don't care. Why?
If i didn't put my idea clear, please, say so, I'll explain it.

[scarface09]

whats the point of this, if there is no public demands and if it wont be implemeted? I don't understand what your trying to do.

[KYnetiK]

He wants a stickied list for the lesser ideas that arent 'public demands' but still good ideas in their own right, for the purpose of keeping track of those good ideas which were still well supported but need that extra shove.


Not fussed. Not necessary, but not a bad thing either.

[Gotfryd]

He wants a stickied list for the lesser ideas that arent 'public demands' but still good ideas in their own right, for the purpose of keeping track of those good ideas which were still well supported but need that extra shove.

Exactly. And I'd like to have this list as a part of Official Suggestions Sticky.
Thank you.

[SadistAtHeart]

So you want a "Controversial Suggestions" list? Seems like a good idea to me.

[Gotfryd]

So you want a "Controversial Suggestions" list?

Maybe not controversial ones. I was thinking more about reasonable suggestions which just didn't make it to be public demands.

[echo_trail]

I think you blokes might be reading too much into this suggestion thing.