Melee or Brawl?

[numgun]

I have not played brawl, but I have the n64 one and the melee.

So my vote goes to melee because it kicks ass.
One thing I dont like about brawl is how the whole gameplay is heavily nerfed compared to the older games.
I've been watching some videos of brawls, so I might be wrong, but they really gave me a picture that the attacks lack MEAT.

Then they made my fav kirby look gay in brawl. Assholes.

[LtKillroy]

And why, OH WHY, did they remove Roy? Roy and Marth were my absolute favorites back in Melee. Marth vs. the fast enemies and Roy vs. the slow ones - an unbeatable team!

Because Ike is pretty much the exact same as Roy.

One of the only things I didn't like about Brawl were the items. Some have pretty much no use, while others (smash tokens and whatever from Kirby's Air Ride) pretty much guarantee you will kill someone or everyone,

[iDante]

One of the only things I didn't like about Brawl were the items. Some have pretty much no use, while others (smash tokens and whatever from Kirby's Air Ride) pretty much guarantee you will kill someone or everyone,

I almost never play with items, but when I do bumpers+bombs with items on high is pretty awesome.

[blackdevil0742]

Brawl by far. Melee had too many exploits and Brawls has Metaknight, though I also play Lucarion ebcause of his way of play ;3

[Espadon]

I was talking to this girl I liked and somehow we got into a big conversation about our favorite SSB characters.

And then she paused and said she was getting way too into it and had to stop.

[numgun]

Brawl by far. Melee had too many exploits and Brawls has Metaknight, though I also play Lucarion ebcause of his way of play ;3

Lucario is my type aswell. Badass kungfoo and ranged energy attacks. Not to mention his powers grow the more he's hurt. Oh and his final smash? Oh dear lord YES.

Goddamn I want to try brawl. : I

[iDante]

Lucario is my type aswell. Badass kungfoo and ranged energy attacks. Not to mention his powers grow the more he's hurt. Oh and his final smash? Oh dear lord YES.

His final smash is HORRIBLE! So easy to dodge as almost anyone, in fact any character with decent jumps can dodge it all out and not get hit by it at all.

Noone beats wario.

[a-4-year-old]

I hate brawl I will never forgive it for giving DK the worst final smash ever.

[numgun]

Lucario is my type aswell. Badass kungfoo and ranged energy attacks. Not to mention his powers grow the more he's hurt. Oh and his final smash? Oh dear lord YES.

His final smash is HORRIBLE! So easy to dodge as almost anyone, in fact any character with decent jumps can dodge it all out and not get hit by it at all.

Noone beats wario.

Its not about that. Its just massively awesome to be able to fire a massive laser. If you hit anyone with it, its just a plus.

[tehsnipah]

The good of Brawl: better graphic & stylish finishers, maybe also nice maps
The bad of Brawl: too many bonuses (in my view)
The ugly of Brawl: three Kirby characters in one game? too much -_-

The good of Melee: original rules, better graphic, and nice balances
The bad of Melee: as I said, Brawl beats Melee's graphic and sounds
The ugly of Melee: god f**k the floating hands

As a result: Melee is my choice.

And if you guys are talking about finishers, let Link's close slash bashing or Mario's fire wave give you tears.