I like the #3 design.
There are a few issues though:
Numbers should be alighted right.
Where will be the regged player/Dev shield positions?
What is the first column about? Ids or Caps? If they are caps where will ids be?
I would use Ping instead of MS.
What is the highlighted line about?
I would attach the info about pgup and pgdown at the end of the list instead at the bottom of the page.
Example:
james bob 1 1 139
joe jamson 0 0 100
press [pgdn] to scroll