10 Clones Solve A puzzle. (Thought Topic)

[PANZERCATWAGON]

the only type of clone that youd be able to produce exactly the same result out of would be a parallel universe clone in which both universes are exactly the same in terms of energy and mass and both universes are happening at the same point along the same timeline

though its still possible youd get differences between the two using that method

[Wolf_Man]

Id say they'd all have to experience their lives exactly the same up until the puzzle, and then have it presented to them in the same way. Unless, of course, its a multi-path puzzle.

[Gnoblar]

Stop trying to make it realistic. It's never going to happen, so stop trying to make it work or not. Just hypothesise the answer.

[demoniac93]

Hypothetical answer is: They can't. Because you cannot copy a human memory. Neither fully provide the needed conditions.

[smiluu]

If all their circumstances, conditions, time, air and whereabouts are mirrored, then they would.
Ofcourse human mind can't be copied, but this is "thought/what if topic".

[Rai-Dei]

I'd say different because I usually attack puzzles in more than one way. I'm not going to start the same way every time, its up to the clones to pick which one of my paths they choose to follow.

[Lord Frunkamunch]

Hypothetical answer is: They can't. Because you cannot copy a human memory. Neither fully provide the needed conditions.

But the question states that those conditions are already met. Do you have any idea what hypothetical means?

[echo_trail]

I'd say the requirement for this experiment to have the same result for all the clones is impossible to meet. Even though, in this case, the requirements have been met, it's just not realistic enough for me to provide a proper answer. Any small difference in said clones upbringing could ultimately lead to him/her selecting a different approach to a task compared to another. Small things that happen throughout reality are all factors that, even if on a very small scale, may alter a persons understanding and behaviour, and such factors are somewhat random. In any case, it's too random to be predicted, even in a controlled invironment.

However, I do believe in a persons mind to be 'more' than just a set of chemical releases, so if I had to guess to save my life, I'd say they would solve the puzzle differently.

[demoniac93]

Hypothetical answer is: They can't. Because you cannot copy a human memory. Neither fully provide the needed conditions.

But the question states that those conditions are already met. Do you have any idea what hypothetical means?

An event, condition, status...etc. imagined or suggested but not necessarily real or true...

[smiluu]

An event, condition, status...etc. imagined or suggested but not necessarily real or true...

I think that was a rhetorical question...

[demoniac93]

Ugh...I know, that's why i answered it...I'm DUMB! AND PROUD OF IT!
Anyway, i think it's clear, the answer to the question is no. What more to discuss?

[Lord Frunkamunch]

Hypothetical answer is: They can't. Because you cannot copy a human memory. Neither fully provide the needed conditions.

But the question states that those conditions are already met. Do you have any idea what hypothetical means?

An event, condition, status...etc. imagined or suggested but not necessarily real or true...

Exactly. Whether or not the situation is possible is irrelevant. The HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION was whether or not they'd react the same way, and in that sense, the answer would be yes.

[demoniac93]

Hypothetical answer is: They can't. Because you cannot copy a human memory. Neither fully provide the needed conditions.

But the question states that those conditions are already met. Do you have any idea what hypothetical means?

An event, condition, status...etc. imagined or suggested but not necessarily real or true...

Exactly. Whether or not the situation is possible is irrelevant. The HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION was whether or not they'd react the same way, and in that sense, the answer would be yes.

UGH! And people say i was sublime, you just pwnd me in that...