first person soldat

[Mistercharles]

^Soldat looks very little like Liero in that it's polygon based. Plus, Michal didn't copy the idea, he was inspired.

[Chariot]

Then it wouldn't be soldat anymore.

Precisely. That should be your perfect answer dream right there.

[Thrax]

You can probely make a FPS Soldat with Flash 8... But I wouldn't play it.. Nope..

[-Vis-]

IMO, if anyone made a 3D Soldat, it should be a third person, not a first person shooter, with small soldiers, to retain the Soldat style (or at least as much as possible for adding another dimension). An FPS would just get drowned in the huge list of more popular FPS games available today.

[echo_trail]

Soldat is soldat because of the simple grafic, yet highly detailed and fast paced gameplay. You should really just leave it like that, I always meant.

I mean, surely there's nothing wrong with experimenting with various changing, but a hole new dimension? It's a hole new game for that.

Anyway it's been done, and it failed horribly.

[SDFilm]

No, because as everyone said on all the times that this '3D Soldat' thing has been suggested, it just won't be soldat anymore.

GUNDAM_SEED, maybe you could make a mod that adds lots of unbalanced weapons, vehicles and maps that are ripped from some other place, then I'm sure it will be shown on Pure Pwnage.com! Yaa!

[Will]

Is he retarded or something. Soldats gameplay is as good as the players are . Soldat is a game that can be a lot of things. Look @ the dodgeball, TW , racing maps , climbing maps and all the other things that will come in the future. Do you really think that  any fps could have that. And this community where everyone flames you (insert lol hir XD) . There was no game like soldat nor it ever will be.   

[BooBoo McBad]

You realize what makes Soldat so great is it's unique 2D element?

Go away.

[Iq Unlimited]

andswer to this, uh..no

it wouldn't work, because if soldat became 3d 1st of all its HELL to code in 3d, I know that stuff

there's 80 reasons this wouldn't work, these r the top 5.

#1: 1 person made soldat, it takes a team of 40-50 ppl to make a 3d game

#2: soldat is unique BECAUSE it's in 2d, if u put it in 3d it'd become counter-strike

#3: soldat is poly based, hence why only 1 person made this

#4: map editor, you do realise that it's VERY difficult and HARDER THEN HELL to make 3d maps, well, good 1s anyways. HaloCustonEdition has 1, but the ppl who make the good 1s worked on them for 2-3 YEARS, not weeks, not months, YEARS.

#4 1/2: downloading time, oh god, it would take an age and there'd be no way I could dload it xD (44 kbs connection)
 
[edit] #4/ 3/4: a game's only as good as the ppl who paly it and its popularity, this would get like drowned in the 50000000000000000000000000000000 fpses out there. [/edit]

#5: yout stupid, dont suggest pointless stuff, it jsut adds to ure post count when u dont deserver it. 

Iq Unlimited

[Grimreck]

I woudl be ok but it would make moding a real pain you would have to get 3D modaling program or whatever and who's going to have the time to learn + make weapons using it. sidescrolling is good and easy to mod =l

[Sotija]

Soldat is met to be on 2d so NO!

EDIT: IF you want more waepons USE MODS.

[fishfood]

You're just looking for a free FPS, and I can tell it.

Give up.

[Death MachineX350]

#5: yout stupid, dont suggest pointless stuff, it jsut adds to ure post count when u dont deserver it. 

Iq Unlimited

You don't have to point out how stupid someone is to get your point across. Soldat is a 2d game and shall be until it dies or I will kill the person who made it 3d. Thank you for listening. Hopefully it will last until the end of time.

[Foley]

That idea is *rubbish*, as well GUNDAM_SEED, if u want to take a map from Quake 2, fucking how ur gonna import .BSP into Soldat, huh?! It WILL be STEALING!. Anyways Soldat is 2D and if anyone will make it 3D it wont be same fun as 2D! Sorry for replying to old topic but i had to.

[PANZERCATWAGON]

... *Whispers* I think it's a good idea

[Mr Killer]

No No No! Soldat MUST stay in 2D!
3D sux!

[{LAW} Gamer_2k4]

Why would you play Soldat instead of other combat games unless you liked the fact that it was 2D?  I love Soldat the way it is: Fast paced, point and shoot action.  I own several FPS games, and I can honestly say Soldat is better than all of them.  Soldat is fun because it's unique.  If it was a first person game, it would suck for several reasons:
-It would feel exactly like every other FPS game.
-Its graphics would be terrible compared to every other FPS game.
-The maps would have to be completely redone, or they would be terrible.
-MM would have to start charging for it, because he'd need to hire 3D artists and such

Leave Soldat the way it is.  If you think it needs to be first person, you're playing the wrong game.