0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Quote from: As de Espada on November 21, 2009, 11:26:26 pmI think that all remakes should have other names... can you explain why this name change?The decision is based on keeping default map names simple by keeping the "root name" only. If we'd go with adding numbers in the end, we might got some ctf_Ash12 maps in official default list, which is basically the same map.
I think that all remakes should have other names... can you explain why this name change?
In my opinion, it's pretty pointless question. Public servers can change easily old Run or Equinox into Run_old or whatever they like that's what happened with B2b years ago, when this b2b version overwrote the old (in ver. 1.2). It's true that it wouldn't be much pain to keep adding numbers, but meh whatever. However if you got good argument to support for not using original name, I'd consider speaking enesce for it.
The new maps aren't really just "updates". Like Boots said - they're different both visually and gameplay-wise, and IMO they deserve a slight difference in the name. There no need for name change if the only differences are a few minor polygon/scenery tweaks here and there, but those aren't just minor tweaks - they're complete remakes.
Q: Why the map version numbers are gone? Death2 = DeathA: The decision is based on keeping default map names simple and consistant by keeping the "root name" only.
even death was renamed when was added a top route...
My opinion: I completely agree with this. Infact, I think mapmakers should always follow a rule not to add background sceneries EVER. To make the map look good, use a nice contrast of colors, use some trees and bushes (These actually add to the gameplay by letting people hide in them), and use nice shading on the maps. Don't use background sceneries.EXAMPLE: http://img689.imageshack.us/img689/928/examplen.pngThat screen pretty much says it all. The original is crisp, clean, you can see everything in the background, theres no clutter. In the 2nd, theres a shadow jungle in the background, the polygons have sceneries, and in general there is just way too much clutter.
But we got to understand that soldat is not some newgen game. It is a retro game and should have retro looks.