Do any of these suggestions ever even make it?

[Splinter-Snake]

I was just wondering if any of the plethora of game improvement suggestions even reach the corner of MM's eyes. I don't remember seeing a suggestion implemented in a while.

[Toumaz]

Not necessarily MM, but I recall EnEsCe saying that he read through the suggestions section for new ideas, and that he took most if not all into consideration. Can't possibly be arsed to find his exact post, but it was somewhere along those lines.

[homerofgods]

well, it still sux, and I must agree with splinter. but we can't do a poo about it.
and can I ask if the bugs are being fixed? in the need help/report bugs section.
I feel like soldat is slowly dying

[Splinter-Snake]

Not necessarily MM, but I recall EnEsCe saying that he read through the suggestions section for new ideas, and that he took most if not all into consideration. Can't possibly be arsed to find his exact post, but it was somewhere along those lines.

Alright. I know I'm as active as a bag of chips on these forums, so I'm not the best guy to be asking the questions. In other words, I'm not sure what suggestions went into the beta for 1.5. I'm guessing the radio chat was a suggestion?

[Gotfryd]

Imo if we are in doubts about this we could ask EnEsCe whether he read (at least) the list of public demands in Official Suggestion Sticky, but NOT NOW (because now he is finishing 1.5 and he won't add more features to it, only fix exisiting bugs). I think we should do it about 2 or 3 months after 1.5 release, he should have time then.

[Splinter-Snake]

Imo if we are in doubts about this we could ask EnEsCe whether he read (at least) the list of public demands in Official Suggestion Sticky, but NOT NOW (because now he is finishing 1.5 and he won't add more features to it, only fix exisiting bugs). I think we should do it about 2 or 3 months after 1.5 release, he should have time then.

Hmm. Maybe this is asking too much, but I'd personally like to see a list of "Game Improvements/Suggestions," that have been implemented, and the names of the people who submitted them. That way this part of the forum won't feel like a simple fantasizing thing. Instead people would have reassurance that their suggestion actually has a chance of getting in.

[Gotfryd]

Hmm. Maybe this is asking too much, but I'd personally like to see a list of "Game Improvements/Suggestions," and the names of the people who submitted them.

Unfortunately some ideas are silly (here's an example), so I don't agree that every suggestion should be listed, but I agree that reasonable and supported ideas should be listed somewhere. I've made a topic about this here - you are welcome to post comments and vote!

[EnEsCe]

As Toumaz said , I read every topic in Game Improvements / Suggestions. Individual people will not be credited for ideas that get added either.

[Splinter-Snake]

Hmm. Maybe this is asking too much, but I'd personally like to see a list of "Game Improvements/Suggestions," and the names of the people who submitted them.

Unfortunately some ideas are silly (here's an example), so I don't agree that every suggestion should be listed, but I agree that reasonable and supported ideas should be listed somewhere. I've made a topic about this here - you are welcome to post comments and vote!

Oh damn. I said the wrong thing. What I meant was I wish there was a list of "Game improvements/Suggestions" that have been implemented.

[miketh2005]

As Toumaz said , I read every topic in Game Improvements / Suggestions. Individual people will not be credited for ideas that get added either.

have you considered my idea of alternative sceneries? it would be nice if you would reply and say why it cant be implemented or why you wont do it or your gonna consider to put it in 1.5.1

[muzikman]

I've posted a couple of suggestions- they just mainly get ignored

[iDante]

I got a suggestion implemented - it made me feel good.
It's important to remember that the idea needs to be doable and popular in order to be implemented. If it's something small and useful then there's a good chance it will be implemented.

[a-4-year-old]

My suggestion was brilliant and awesome people agreed (except Geologist, hes not cool anymore )

http://forums.soldat.pl/index.php?topic=10452.0

[Xxypher]

I had a suggestion get altered and make it in 1.4... Lemme go find it.

[EnEsCe]

Don't turn this into a 'HEY! Look at my idea!' thread.

[a-4-year-old]

Individual people will not be credited for ideas that get added either.

Thats bullshit, you get your name on it why can't someone else.

[SpiltCoffee]

A simple credits page would suffice, listing all the people's ideas that made it in.

Ok, who wants to find out who was responsible for each feature?





Eh, fuck it then.

[-Major-]

most suggestions are not unique. so giving credits would be really hard to do...

[EnEsCe]

Individual people will not be credited for ideas that get added either.

Thats bulls**t, you get your name on it why can't someone else.

As -Major- just said most (if not all) ideas are not unique. If credit was given for 'ideas', 8 out of 10 times there would be someone who will strongly believe it was originally their idea. Just knowing "your" idea was considered and successfully implemented should be enough.

[muzikman]

Don't turn this into a 'HEY! Look at my idea!' thread.

Ok, but look at my thread about switching grenade types

[scarface09]

players should get credited for their ideas, this is what brings soldat into a community.

[Gotfryd]

Generally I agree with -major- and EnEsCe: crediting every idea would only create mess.
Actual work (coding, drawing, making animations, default maps and sceneries) is of couse a different thing and should be credited for sure (and it is, I believe).

[homerofgods]

jesus kids, you don't need credit for suggesting an improvement. If your suggestion is good, it will be done, isn't that enough?

[miketh2005]

Individual people will not be credited for ideas that get added either.

Thats bulls**t, you get your name on it why can't someone else.

As -Major- just said most (if not all) ideas are not unique. If credit was given for 'ideas', 8 out of 10 times there would be someone who will strongly believe it was originally their idea. Just knowing "your" idea was considered and successfully implemented should be enough.

I would just like a list of the suggestions that were implemented in versions of soldat, thats all, not people getting credited. Also, my idea of replying to every reasonable idea would be more welcome.

[jrgp]

Individual people will not be credited for ideas that get added either.

Thats bulls**t, you get your name on it why can't someone else.

As -Major- just said most (if not all) ideas are not unique. If credit was given for 'ideas', 8 out of 10 times there would be someone who will strongly believe it was originally their idea. Just knowing "your" idea was considered and successfully implemented should be enough.

I would just like a list of the suggestions that were implemented in versions of soldat, thats all, not people getting credited. Also, my idea of replying to every reasonable idea would be more welcome.

Posting in a thread that's been dead for 7 months replying to a quote from last year? wth?

Locked / warned for necroposting.

(and you could just check the huge changelog that comes with each version of Soldat)